Ice Cream · 48oz / 1.5 QT
Peanut Butter Cup
The PB-Chocolate Combo You Love. Now a Full Tub. Toft's Peanut Butter Cup™ is the flavor for the person who's been buying peanut butter cup candy for decades and finally decided to bring it home in ice cream form. A genuine peanut butter ice cream base — made with fresh Ohio dairy — is loaded with real peanut butter cup pieces that deliver the exact combination of creamy PB and chocolate you've been chasing since childhood. Rich, crunchy, and genuinely impossible to stop eating.
- No artificial growth hormones (rBST-free milk from all partner farms)
- Gluten Free
- Kosher Certified
- Allergen Alert: Contains Milk, Peanuts & Soy
Full ingredients & nutrition from Toft clean-label 2026 product documents · code 725.
Available Sizes
The full story
Peanut Butter Cup™: The Candy You Crave in Ice Cream Form
Peanut butter cup ice cream is only as good as two things: the quality of the peanut butter base and the quality of the cup inclusions. Toft's delivers on both fronts without compromise.
The peanut butter ice cream is built on fresh Ohio dairy from family farms within 50 miles of our Sandusky plant — the same quality foundation we bring to every product. That quality base ensures the peanut butter flavor is genuine, creamy, and satisfying. This isn't artificially flavored peanut butter approximation; it's the real thing.
The peanut butter cup pieces are generous, well-distributed, and deliver the exact chocolate-and-peanut-butter experience you're looking for. Each piece brings texture — the crunch of chocolate, the creaminess of peanut butter filling — and flavor complexity. Some scoops are more peanut-butter-forward, others bring more chocolate into the mix, but every scoop carries the full peanut butter cup experience.
The combination is irresistible: creamy peanut butter base, chunks of chocolate-and-peanut-butter candy, fresh Ohio dairy quality throughout. This is the flavor for the person who loves peanut butter cups without apology and wants them available by the scoop.
Available in 48oz tub format. Contains peanuts. Gluten-free, Kosher certified, rBST-free.
